Very helpful, Thank you!

I've gotten "Grilled fish that impressed Paimon" from Bass and Pufferfish, but grilling Medaka that way only results in Charred Fish... So, it is possible to make this recipe from anything BUT Medaka.

Grilled Fish that broke through the Dimensions for me was Golden Bass, Heavy Seasoning, Cooked too long.

Perfectly-grilled golden bass is wrong. That recipe makes Ordinary Grilled Fish.
This whole guide is filled with incorrect recipes.

Seconding recipe for fresh and juicy grilled fish being wrong. Well done one side, rare the other.

Yo,

Just a tip for everyone trying to get the special dishes, it´s rng.

i got 3 of them using the exact same method, just right and only 1 sparkle in each side.

Good luck.

The recipe for fresh and juicy grilled fish is wrong.

You have to cook to half-done instead.

did a number one grilled fish in teyvat
fish: any
seasoning: just right
what i did was flipped when white smoke was shown 4 times, do it until well done and then when you see a gold sparkle you immediately take it out

 Click to Enlarge

I tried the suggested recipe for Number One Grilled Fish - Medaka, Just-Right, Well-Done.
It worked for me; I think you have to take the fish out as soon as it's Well-Done and get both sides Well-Done around the same time.

Explosive and Overloaded Grilled Fish
Fish: Any fish
Seasoning: Just right
Cook: Don't flip the fish. Just wait until the fish is well done on one side only.

 Click to Enlarge

I want to make Amazing Grilled Fish that Impressed Paimon 2 but I got this instead

That grilled fish paimon 2 says to cook it well-done and overcooked right? So it just the opposite which is : well-done one side, and rare the other side. The seasoning is just right

 Click to Enlarge

Did the Explosive and Overloaded Grilled Fish using Pufferfish, Right seasoning and just waited for a bit. Flipped every time a smoke AND gold sparkle appeared. Pretty sure it doesn't matter that I kept flipping but after like 5 gold sparkles, I took it out.

I got the Explosive and Overloaded Grilled Fish with Pufferfish, Just Right seasoning, and cooked rare on one side then flipped and cooked to well done on the other.

was trying to make charred grilled fish and got amazing fish that impressed paimon
medaka
just right
cook both side well-done but don't take it out instantly when a black smoke came then just pick it up

 Click to Enlarge

I was attempting to make an Exquisite Medaka Dish (Medaka Fish, Just Right Seasoning & Well-Done Cook) and somehow got this instead.

not entirely sure if it needs to be specifically a Medaka Fish but just wanted to share how I got this.

 Click to Enlarge

Apparently, you can make grilled fish beyond space and time with a well done pufferfish and just right seasoning

Grilled fish beyond space and time is both sides fully cooked Medaka with just right seasoning.

Trying for "Fresh and Juicy Grilled Fish" gave me secret "Number One Grilled Fish in Teyvat"

 Click to Enlarge

Medaka with just right seasoning while grilling rare also gives Amazing Grilled fish that impressed Paimon

Amazing grilled fish that impressed paimon is overcooked pufferfish and just right seasoning

Wild Style Grilled Bitter Pufferfish is well done on one side, rare o the other, and has just right seasoning

Perfectly Grilled Golden Bass is Golden Bass, Just right seasoning and Well Done

grilled fish that broke through dimensions doesn't require any seasoning

Exquisite Medaka Dish is Rare Medaka with Just Right seasoning.