This is a strategy guide for Smithy in Super Mario RPG Remake. It explains Smithy's weaknesses, countermeasures, recommended party members, and equipment, so please use it as a reference for how to defeat him.
Table of Contents
Smithy's Weaknesses
Smithy
![]() | HP | 2000 |
---|---|---|
EXP | 0 | |
Map | Weapon World |
Jump | Fire | Ice | Thunder |
---|---|---|---|
- | - | - | - |
Fear | Poison | Sleep | Silence |
× | × | × | × |
Smelter
![]() | HP | 1500 |
---|---|---|
EXP | 0 | |
Map | Weapon World |
Jump | Fire | Ice | Thunder |
---|---|---|---|
- | - | - | ◎ |
Fear | Poison | Sleep | Silence |
× | × | × | × |
Freshly Made Shyper
![]() | HP | 400 |
---|---|---|
EXP | 0 | |
Map | Weapon World |
Jump | Fire | Ice | Thunder |
---|---|---|---|
- | - | - | - |
Fear | Poison | Sleep | Silence |
× | × | × | × |
Smithy Strategy and Countermeasures
- Prepare for status ailments
- Defeat the Smelter first
- Maneuver while using Peach for party healing
- Focus attacks on the head
- Use Red Yoshi Extract during the magic form
Prepare for Status Ailments

Smithy, in his second form, has multiple moves that inflict status ailments on the entire party. Prioritize equipping Peach, the healer, with accessories that can counter all status ailments.
Defeat the Smelter First

The Smelter produces 'Freshly Made Shypers.' Freshly Made Shypers use the party-wide attack 'Rain Sword,' so if multiple are produced, maintaining HP becomes difficult.
Having Konpeito Candies Provides Stability
If multiple Freshly Made Shypers are generated, it's recommended to use the item 'Konpeito Candy' for a party-wide attack. Geno Wave can enhance the damage of Konpeito Candies, so use them in combination.
Konpeito Candy Effects and How to GetManeuver While Using Peach for Party Healing

In the Smithy battle, party-wide attacks are used frequently, so be careful of the possibility of being defeated all at once when HP is low. Always keep HP topped up with a comfortable margin.
Weaknesses Differ for Each Form in the Latter Half of the Battle

When Smithy's HP is reduced to a certain point, the battlefield changes, and Smithy's form changes. Attack patterns and weaknesses will change, so accurately exploit weaknesses to deal damage efficiently.
Summary of Features for Each Form
Form | Features |
---|---|
![]() | - Low magic defense - Physical defense is also subsequently low |
![]() | - Weak to Thunder, low magic defense - Possesses an instant-death attack |
![]() | - Weak to Fire, slightly low magic defense - Possesses multiple status ailment attacks |
![]() | - Weak to Ice, slightly low magic defense - Possesses means to remove buffs and heal |
![]() | - Low physical defense - High magic attack power - Powerful non-elemental party-wide magic attack |
※Forms change randomly
Focus Attacks on the Head

The body revives even if defeated, so focus attacks only on the head. Defeating the head will result in victory.
Use Red Yoshi Extract During the Magic Form

If you have Red Yoshi Extract, it's recommended to use it during the magic form. While the magic form's powerful party-wide attacks are troublesome, if you can deal with them using invincibility, you can exploit its low defense weakness to deal massive damage.
Recommended Party and Equipment
Recommended Party
Mario
Lazy Shell (Weapon)
Hero Shirt
Safety Badge
Geno
Star Gun
Work Pants
Safety Ring
Peach
Frying Pan
Lazy Shell (Armor)
Defense Scarf
Enhance allies' attack and defense with Geno's 'Geno Wave,' with Mario and Geno taking on offensive roles. Peach should focus on healing.
Recommended Equipment
Armor
Lazy Shell (Armor)
Defense+127M.Def+127Strongest durability. Nullifies all status ailments and reduces elemental damage.
EffectAttack-50, Magic-50, Speed-50
Prevents all status ailments
Reduces all elemental damage by 70% (100% on Enjoy difficulty)Super Jumper
Defense+50M.Def+50Strongest armor. Equip with highest priority if you have it.
EffectAttack+50, Magic+50, Speed+30
Prevents all status ailments
Reduces all elemental damage by 70% (100% on Enjoy difficulty)
Accessories
Safety Ring
Defense+5M.Def+5Speed+5Excellent for nullifying all status ailments and reducing elemental damage.
EffectPrevents all status ailments and instant death
Reduces all elemental damage by 70% (100% on Enjoy difficulty)Safety Badge
Defense+5M.Def+5Nullifies all status ailments.
EffectPrevents Silence, Scarecrow, Fear, Mushroom, Sleep, and Poison statuses.
Smithy's Special Moves
Light Saber (Before Form Change)

Deals fire-elemental magic damage to a single target with Light Saber.
Megaton Hammer (Before Form Change)

A giant hammer deals non-elemental magic damage to the entire party.
Milky Meteor Shower (Before Change & Magic Form)

A rainbow meteor shower deals non-elemental magic damage to the entire party. Used by Smithy before form change and in magic form.
Shyper Production (Smelter)

Generates Freshly Made Shypers to fight.
Rain Sword (Freshly Made Shyper & Magic Form)

Makes countless swords rain down, dealing non-elemental magic damage to the entire party. Used by Freshly Made Shypers and Smithy in magic form.
Magnum (Tank Form)

Fires a magnum, instantly killing a single target.
Party Status Ailment Attack (Treasure Chest Form)

Emits a wave from the treasure chest, inflicting one random status ailment from 'Fear,' 'Silence,' 'Scarecrow,' or 'Poison' on the entire party.
Peel Off (Coffin Form)

Removes all buffs applied to Mario and his allies.
Heal (Coffin Form)

Recovers its own HP.
Full Heal (Coffin Form)

Greatly recovers its own HP.
Dark Star (Magic Form)

Deals non-elemental magic damage to a single target with Dark Star.
Rock Rattle (Magic Form)

Rolls numerous rocks, dealing non-elemental magic damage to the entire party.
Rain Arrow (Magic Form)

Makes countless arrows rain down, dealing non-elemental magic damage to the entire party.
Rain Spear (Magic Form)

Makes countless spears rain down, dealing non-elemental magic damage to the entire party.
Flavor Text
Smithy
Hmph?
Not bad at all.Come!I'll reforge you all!!―From "The Sayings of Smithy"
Smithy (True Form)
Mmm, not bad.
This is bad. Very bad.NUOOOOHHHH!!!!
―From "Smithy's Famous Quotes"
Smithy (Tank)
I'm a precision machine, so
I'm weak to electricity!A tank doesn't need an engine to run.
Because it's in my head.
―From "My Name is Smithy"
Smithy (Coffin)
I have no weaknesses! Time to heal up!
"I'll put you all in coffins!"
He intended to say, but ended up getting in one himself.
―From "Learning from the Tyrant's Failures"
Smithy (Magician)
Magic is strong, but defense is weak.
Miracle Transformation☆ I'll cast
Milky magic on your heart, zoinks!
―From "Magical Artisan Magical☆KajiKaji-kun"
Smithy (Treasure Chest)
What comes out is a surprise♡
Head change to Treasure Box Mode!!
Surprised by the box opening? Gimmick ON!
―From "Easy to Understand! Smithy's Secrets"
Freshly Made Shyper
Freshly made and piping hot♡
As explained in the Shyper section, indeed,
Shypers are not Shy Guys, but were created
by Smithy!