Check out this guide for a full walkthrough of the Chapter 2 - Polite Society, Valentine Style from Red Dead Redemption 2, including gameplay tips, guides, and more!
Mission Walkthrough
Check Out Chapter 2 Mission WalkthroughTable of Contents
Chapter 2: Horseshoe Overlook - Mission Chart
Polite Society, Valentine Style - Mission Challenge List
Mission Challenge List
| No. | Mission Challenge |
|---|---|
| 1 | Return the lost wagon horse to its owner |
| 2 | Find Karen within 45 seconds |
Ride To Valentine
Ride To Valentine - Walkthrough Chart
| No. | Procedure |
|---|---|
| 1 | Drive the carriage with the girls to Valentine. Follow the trail on your map. |
| 2 | CHOICE: Help the man who lost his horse, or continue riding to Valentine. |
| 3 | Arrive at Valentine, and pass through the main street. |
| 4 | Park near the stables at the end of the main street. |
| 5 | Follow Uncle to the General Store as you send the girls to collect information. |
2. Helping The Man Will Complete A Challenge
Before arriving at Valentine, you will encounter a man who loses a horse from his carriage. Bring it back to him to complete on of the mission challenges.
Check Out World Map & Locations HereHelp Tilly & Karen
Help Tilly & Karen - Walkthrough Chart
| No. | Procedure |
|---|---|
| 1 | CHOICE: Intervene or Defuse the argument between Tilly and a man. |
| 2 | Look for Karen in the Hotel near the Butcher. |
| 3 | Fight the drunk who hurt Karen. |
1. Choose Between To Defuse or Intervene
Here, you will be given the choice to Defuse or Intervene in the argument between Tilly and a man. Choosing to Defuse will make the man walk away from Tilly saying "You're making a big mistake, Tilly Jackson."
2. Ask The Hotel Owner Where Karen Is
You can ask the Hotel Owner where Karen is to find her faster. The Hotel Owner will say that Karen is in the second floor, Room 2B.
Deal With The Man From Blackwater
Chase The Man From Blackwater - Walkthrough Chart
| No. | Procedure |
|---|---|
| 1 | Follow the man on your horse through the barn south of Valentine. |
| 2 | Make a right after exiting the Auction Yard near the barn. |
| 3 | Get off the road, and chase the man through an open field. |
1~3. This Is A Linear Mission Sequence
To be able to catch up with the man, just follow him on your minimap. General directions have been provided in the walkthrough chart above to give you a rough outline of the man's route.
Deal With The Man From Blackwater - Walkthrough Chart
| No. | Procedure |
|---|---|
| 1 | CHOICE: Question or Kill the man from Blackwater. |
| 2 | CHOICE: Help or Kill the man from Blackwater. |
1. Question Or Kill The Man From Blackwater
You will be given a choice to Question or Kill the man from Blackwater as he hangs from a cliff. Questioning him will intimidate him, and later on allow you to help him up the cliff. No. 2 will not happen if you decide to kill him here.
Check Out The Fame & Honor System Here2. Help Or Kill The Man From Blackwater
If you chose to Question the man from Blackwater, you now have a choice of helping him up, or killing him. Helping him up will reward you with honor.
Next Mission: Americans At RestRed Dead Redemption 2 Related Article
Mission Walkthrough
Chapter 2: Horseshoe Overlook - Mission Chart
Story Mission Walkthrough Per Chapter
| Chapter Walkthrough | |
|---|---|
| Chapter 1 | Chapter 2 |
| Chapter 3 | Chapter 4 |
| Chapter 5 | Chapter 6 |
| Epilogue 1 | Epilogue 2 |
