Check out this guide for a full walkthrough of the Companion Side Mission - Good, Honest, Snake Oil Mission from Red Dead Redemption 2, including gameplay tips, guides, and more!
Hunt Down The Criminal
Camp / Companion Side Missions will disappear once you move forward in the story. Make sure to take & complete them before proceeding to the next chapter.
Hunt Down The Criminal - Walkthrough Chart
|1||Go to the sheriff's office in Valentine|
|2||Look for the target at the Gorge near the river|
|3||Confront the criminal|
|4||Pull Benedict from the cliff|
|6||Take him back to the Sheriff's office|
|7||Put him down in the holding cell|
5. Make Sure to Capture Benedict Alive
You'll get a better payout if you bring Benedict back alive instead of a corpse. Use your lasso to stop him from getting away, then hogtie him so you can carry him back to your horse.